PDA

View Full Version : Engine died down at high RPM.


mushman
05-10-2008, 07:18 AM
I put the boat in this morning, took her out for a good run.It was going great for a while, but after I opened it up for a minute she died down from 4200 to like 2500, I thought it stalled out.
I threw it in neutral and saw it was still running so I threw it into gear and there she went.
I kept it at low rpm heading back to port, the throttle seemed to be pushed farther down than usual, but the rpms stayed low.
It idles fine, and starts right up,and all the plugs seem to be getting spark.
I didn't open it up again because I didn't want to get stuck and have to call for a tow.
I didn't run it last year, but I did drain all but 15 gallons of gas out of it last week,then added 10 gallons fresh gas ,oil,and sea foam.
I just changed the thermostats also, the old ones were shot.
I did notice that the 3 starboard plugs were really "wet" while the port plugs looked alost new.
I hope it's a fuel issue or something managable, because I can't afford a new powerhead right now.
It's a 1986 150 hp v6 Evinrude.
Thanks.
http://www.wellcraftv20.com/community/images/misc/progress.gif

tsubaki
05-10-2008, 07:22 AM
Bubble flat due to vent blockage or the like?
Fuel hose crimped? (this did happen to me once on another boat, the cooler was mashing the fuel line)
Filter possibly almost stopped up?

Don't like the sound of one side keeping the plugs wet.

mushman
05-10-2008, 08:00 AM
Thanks Tsubaki,I was just reading another thread at continuouswave, and fuel,water issue seem to give same almost the same syptoms for the bogging, which would make me happy.
I don't like the one side getting fouled up either.Any ideas on what may cause this?.
I dread the thought that it may be the PH, and of course that's all I can think of right now.
I did notice when I was draining the gas that I was seeing lots of air bubbles getting into my syphon tube.I had it connected to the gas inlet under the cowling.Is this normal?, it would bubble up so much it would stop the flow so I had to keep pressing the bubble the whole time.

macojoe
05-10-2008, 08:13 AM
I had the same thing happen to mine, low RPM's and wet plugs on one side. It was a power pack.

Mine was 86 175 so they are the same motor. Skools told me the deal at the time. I forgot how I tested it?? Or I just bought one and changed it?

Well Therm, Spare, Skools, and the rest will be by soon to help.

Good luck

steplift20
05-10-2008, 08:41 AM
lets not go crazy thinking the worst
it sounds like a fuel problem to me
do you have a fuel/water sepperator?
if you do change it also check the vent line on the outside of the hull make sure its clean and open
could also be an electric problem
stator/switchbox
oh wait i just remembered the switch box operates half of the plugs so went it cuts off it will shut them down causing half to get wet
while its running bad be careful and pull 1 wire off hold it to the block and see if your getting spark then the other side if no spark the switch box is the culprit
you didnt say what kind of engine you have
i had the same problem with my merc but it was sounding the oil alarm it depends on what switch box is bad it would run great then throttle would cut to half speed with the oil alarm going off

steplift20
05-10-2008, 08:43 AM
a 150 evenrude i should have read to the bottom sorry but it can still be the same problem let us know there easy to change on a merc

mushman
05-10-2008, 08:51 AM
Thank guys, It's a 1986 150hp 6 cyl Evinrude.I'd be happy with either the power pack (power pack looks to be just under 100)or switch(havn't looked that one up yet).
When I had the engine running at idle back at port I pulled each wire and I could hear the spark clicking and feel the engine bog.It would right itself once I plugged it back in.
I never held it to the block though.
Steplift, are you saying do them one at a time, disconnect then reconnect and move on, or disconnect one side leave it off then disconnect the other side?.
Thanks again guys.:beer:

macojoe
05-10-2008, 09:01 AM
I did the same now that I remember, while running pull the wire off one plug, then again on the other side, one side makes no difference then thats the bad side. and means the switch.
I did that to find out why my motor was not shutting down after I shut it off, the yellow & Black wire on the left side was not connected, I found the break and all was well again

macojoe
05-10-2008, 09:07 AM
Here are a few threads that were going at my time.

http://www.wellcraftv20.com/community/showthread.php?t=7912&highlight=power+pack

http://www.wellcraftv20.com/community/showthread.php?t=3473&highlight=power+pack

http://www.wellcraftv20.com/community/showthread.php?t=7876&highlight=power+pack

tsubaki
05-10-2008, 09:18 AM
We had a 115 do the same thing.
After a couple of weeks swapping powerpacks, unplugging plug wires, etc,etc, we found in a repair manuel somewhere how to test the powerpacks (gave resistance values).
The powerpack did work but had weak values at high rpms when warmed up.
Come to find out the first powerpack purchased was also bad, apparently someone used it, returned it and they resold it.
Try the cheap and easy stuff first (might as well call it annual maintenance), plus it gives you a piece of mind.

mushman
05-10-2008, 09:37 AM
I have the clymers manual it has a voltage test I'm going to try first.
I did find some on ebay from 55.00 and up.While I'm at it I'll try the plugs to see if the switch is bad, and remove the fuel water separator and see what's in there, plus check the vent.
Does the air in the fuel line sound like it could be an issue?.Should I try changing the bulb out?.

tsubaki
05-10-2008, 09:40 AM
What boat do you have?
Better yet where are the fuel tank(s) located?
Almost sounds like a split at the top of the pickup tube in the tank.

tsubaki
05-10-2008, 09:45 AM
Air in the line could be a number of things.
Usually it will straighten out by pumping the bubble till it's hard.
If no fuel leaks or smells are evident and the air persists, you may have to check the pickup tube coming out of the tank for a split.

mushman
05-10-2008, 10:21 AM
It's a 1986 steplift, the tank is in between pedestal and back to back seats in the front of the boat right before you step into the cuddy.
I was using a clear hose to get the old gas out and I kept getting so many bubbles in there it would kill my syphon flow.
I had it attached to the fuel line before it went into the fuel filter under the cowling.
I didn't clamp it, but it was a real tight fit, and I didn't see bubbles comming in from around the seal.
How would I check the pickup tube for a split?.

tsubaki
05-10-2008, 10:49 AM
If you're sure there aren't any loose connections between the tank and the point where you're getting the bubbles, remove the hose at the tank and try the same thing at the fitting at the tank.
Useing the clear hose helps a lot.
I'm sure this is going to involve removing a floor hatch and a lot of other crap.
Try everything else first, replacing filters, checking for loose connections (there should be a gas leak)
If you have to access the tank, might as well inspect the fitting and tube by removing it. Last resort.

tsubaki
05-10-2008, 10:55 AM
The pickup tube rests down below the place where the fittings tighten into the tank and have a filter.
http://i175.photobucket.com/albums/w159/tsubaki3/Picture065.jpg
The fittings have a ball valve in them to reduce siphoning.
http://i175.photobucket.com/albums/w159/tsubaki3/Picture074.jpg
Try everything else first.

steplift20
05-10-2008, 01:28 PM
i would check each wire see if your getting spark
the prblem is you can be getting spark but one side can be wee=ak
also check the vent
while your driving and the engine cuts down take the fuel cap off and see if it returns to normal if it doesnt its not the vent

THEFERMANATOR
05-10-2008, 03:21 PM
First things first, get you a helper and go for a ride. Have somebody pump the primer while it is acting up and ses if that clears it up. If it doesn't change anything, swap the powerpacks from side to side. Then see if the wet plugs clean up and the good ones look wet. The simplest ignition diagnostic tool is a spark tester with an adjustable gap in it, you can get them from any auto parts store. Open the gap up to at least 7/16" and check each wire idividually. If you have GOOD bright spark at each cylinder then most likely it isn't an ignition problem. The proper tool is a peak reading volt meter. MAKE CERTAIN THAT IT IS A PRV STYLE METER! Just because your meter says it will measure peak voltage, doesn't mean it will read correctly. My DVOM would read barely good on some systems and great on others, but with the CDI PRV adapter it reads consistent voltage. If you don't have access to one, then try swapping the packs from side to side. This will help you to narrow it down if it's a pack or not. The PRV eliminates alot of the guesswork though.

tsubaki
05-10-2008, 03:34 PM
First things first, get you a helper and go for a ride. Have somebody pump the primer while it is acting up and ses if that clears it up. If it doesn't change anything, swap the powerpacks from side to side. Then see if the wet plugs clean up and the good ones look wet. The simplest ignition diagnostic tool is a spark tester with an adjustable gap in it, you can get them from any auto parts store. Open the gap up to at least 7/16" and check each wire idividually. If you have GOOD bright spark at each cylinder then most likely it isn't an ignition problem. The proper tool is a peak reading volt meter. MAKE CERTAIN THAT IT IS A PRV STYLE METER! Just because your meter says it will measure peak voltage, doesn't mean it will read correctly. My DVOM would read barely good on some systems and great on others, but with the CDI PRV adapter it reads consistent voltage. If you don't have access to one, then try swapping the packs from side to side. This will help you to narrow it down if it's a pack or not. The PRV eliminates alot of the guesswork though.


You gotta love him!!:clap:

mushman
05-10-2008, 07:24 PM
Thanks guys.I'll look into getting the meter.It would be way easier and quicker with the meter than switching packs around.
According to my manual it says to open the 3 wire connector then go one side to ground then crank engine and check 2 wires.My manual has a diagram, and it looks pretty straight forward.
I'm looking for 180v or more right?.What is the minimum before a pack is considered bad?.
I have different volt meters at work I just need to see what the specs are with them, but I won't go there till Monday, so tomorrow I'll try some of the other suggestions before I'll be heading out with the family.

THEFERMANATOR
05-10-2008, 07:54 PM
You check for voltage to ground from the stator first, if any is found then the stator is bad. Then you check the peak voltage coming out of the charge coils(stator), 150 is minumum for your app at cranking speed to the packs(with packs disconnected). Then you'll need a PL-88 to install in place of the coils, and you should have 130 volts minumum there. If you have 150 going in, but less than 130 coming out you'll most likely need a new pack. The next test is for the trigger coil, they should produce 0.4V at cranking speed. Obviously this is much easier with a book in front of you outlining which connectors to check. If you can't find a true PRV meter for testing magnetos, then your best bet is to swap the packs from side to side. It shouldn't take but 10-15 minutes to swap them, and if the problem follows the pack then replace that pack. You can also buy a CDI 511-9773 and use a standard DVOM(digital, not analog). The OMC tool isn't expensive, but it's tough to come by. The CDI adapter lists for $90, but can normally be found for $45 online(unless you need it ASAP, like I did).

Fitz
05-10-2008, 09:21 PM
Mushman:

Before you do anything, I recommend you change all of the spark plug wires. I had the exact same problem and symptoms with a 1989 Evinrude 200.

Powerpack, coils, etc., were suspected (and changed), but the answer turned out to be much simpler and cheaper. My wires looked fine, but several had developed invisible cracks in the insulation which allowed them to arc (ground out the cylinders to which they were attached) at high speeds. Consequently, RPMs went down, and the spark plugs on those cylinders always appeared wet. At idle and low speeds all cylinders had spark, and everything looked fine.

A quick test that will generally confirm an ignition wire problem is to spray all of the wires with silicone, then take a run. The silicone is usually enough to fill any insulation cracks for a short while, so if the engine runs fine, you know it's the wires.

I hope that's your only problem. Under any circumstances, changing the wires every few years is good preventive maintenance.

Skools Out
05-11-2008, 06:48 PM
my 87 Johnson 225 did that it was timing was off and not advancing correctly. but do as Ferm said test with buddy.

macojoe
05-11-2008, 06:50 PM
Hi there stranger were you been?? :hi:

mushman
05-11-2008, 07:12 PM
I didn't get to the boat today, go figure the wife wanted to spend time with her and the kids today, but tomorrow I'll check what I can if its not pouring.
I was looking at the diagrams and I can see how the plugs on each side are related to the each of the two packs.
Would a bad pack bog me down at high rpms?, or can the pack only show signs of failing at high rpms?.
Should I open her up and see if it does it again, or just let it run for a while and take a look at the plugs?.
I think I'll try swapping the packs to see if the plugs on the other side get all fouled up.
I'll get back with results as soon as I get to the boat.

THEFERMANATOR
05-11-2008, 07:27 PM
Bad packs can do all sorts of wacky problems. They can cause them to mis-fire, not fire, and other sorts of hair pulling problems. They are the 1 item that a JOHNNY-RUDE owner should carry for a spare.

bobby2400
05-11-2008, 07:48 PM
Had the same problem today down in Ocean City. On the way back my 96 Johnson 112 would be running 5000 rpm then it would drop to 3500 or so for as little as a second and as much as 10 seconds. Had this problem at the end of the year last year and changed hose and ball also installed new 10 micron racor filter/seperator. Its funny ran for two days fine and then it started acting up. Left tank was near empty so I switched it to the right tank which was full. Sill did it. Its driving me nuts.

macojoe
05-11-2008, 08:24 PM
Bad packs can do all sorts of wacky problems. They can cause them to mis-fire, not fire, and other sorts of hair pulling problems. They are the 1 item that a JOHNNY-RUDE owner should carry for a spare.


I agree!! when mine was bad I went from thinking bad gas, bad plugs, bad coils, bad ball on the fuel line, ect... ect... ect... then I saw a pack on ebay for cheap, I ordered it and all was perfect in the world!!

steplift20
05-12-2008, 07:01 AM
i think we should take a sUrvey to get theferms name changed to
THE MAN WHAT DO YOU THINK

THEFERMANATOR
05-12-2008, 08:43 AM
i think we should take a sUrvey to get theferms name changed to
THE MAN WHAT DO YOU THINK

Nah, it should be "Too much time on his hands".

macojoe
05-12-2008, 09:22 AM
You have to much what in your hands?? :oh:

steplift20
05-12-2008, 10:50 AM
L O L

THEFERMANATOR
05-12-2008, 11:08 AM
I call it time, and I can play with it however I want:sly:.

mushman
05-12-2008, 05:58 PM
We had some nasty weather here today so I didn't get to anything, but I did pass by a marine store today and picked up a new set of plug wires, which I was planning to replace since last year.
The wires he gave me were gray and have Ht on them, the originals were black and say copper core on them.
According to the johnson site they list a different part# than the ones I got.
Will the ones I picked up be o.k., or should I return them and look for the specific part#?.

mushman
05-21-2008, 03:39 PM
I finally got to take the boat out for a good run today after a pretty bad week weather wise, and it looks as if it was either bad fuel, or the wires.
I looked at the old wires with my ohm meter and one of them was so corroded it wouldnt show me a short from one end to the other.
I still have to take a look at the plugs to see how they look, but the weather turned sour again so I'll give it a try later on this week.
The fishing has been getting good around here so I'm glad I'm back up and running.
Thanks to all for the help, I'll look further into the suggestions if the problem shows up again.