v21 vs v20

[buckleyjr]

Does anyone have any thoughts on the v21 vs v20?

I thought they were the same design except for the transom, but I read a recent post that said the freeboard was larger on the v-20 and the scantlings (which I assume are stringers) were different too.


I have owned whalers all my life, but I now need something that works with a wife and baby. I love the style of these boats (remind me of the classic Lyman) and the quality of the hull seems very good. I assumed the v21 would be the best because of the extra foot, and the fact its newer. I also don't have the skills to take a chainsaw a transom, so I want the best hull I can get. Is there any reason that say a 92 v-20 would be better than a 95 v-21, assuming they were in the same condition?

Any thoughts from the board are appreciated - this board has already been an icredible resource for me. I am going to check out a v21 this weekend in Cape May.
Thanks,
John

[macojoe]

I think you will be fine no matter what one you get!!

Check out the spec in the gallery:

http://www.wellcraftv20.com/gallery/view_photo.php?set_albumName=album22&id=1993_catal og_v21steplift

Good Luck!!

[reelapeelin]

Buckley, I've never been face-to-face w/a 21', but I got the HOTS for one big time...my '74 V20 is GREAT...don't get me wrong...it's just that when I do think about "movin'"...all I think about is a fully refurbished 21'... 8)...

NOW that having been said, MJ is right...20 and a 21 of same quality, you can't go wrong with either...unless a 21 just REALLY trips your trigger, don't pass up a 20 thinkin' you're gonna get LOTS more holdin' out for a 21...

Take a look at Pipe Dream's V20 in the Gallery...I wouldn't hold back on something like that waitin' on "the right" 21 to come along... ;)...of course if you run across one like that for sale, get ready for some DEEP diggin'... :o ;D

[fillet1]

Buckley,

The 21 is a 21 b/c of the integrated transom bracket. Its a neat design IMO. If You are looking at a 92 v20 with a full transom with an aftermarket bracket, you may prefer that to the integrated one on the V21. Otherwise, You are looking at a regular outboard on the transom cutout of a v20 vs the v21 with the "better" IMO, transom arrangement.

The 21's are newer, have more modern seating, an integrated fishbox seat, rounded windows that are more modern looking, and have no teak. Whether this is what you want is another question. You like the classic "Lyman" look to the v-20 and I think an older model like Reelapeelin's shows that classic styling better then the more modern touches of the 21.

To answer your question, the only thing "better" about the 20 over the 21 assuming all other things being equal is the price. they are both nice boats.

BTW - I'm In NJ and I'll kep my eyes open for a nice one for ya.

[buckleyjr]

Thanks everyone, this is very helpful. I am taking a v-21 on a sea trial on Sunday out of Cape May. I already went and looked at it last weekend - its in great shape, origional owner. If all goes well, I'll be on the forum Monday as an owner!

The hull on these boats really are a thing a beauty. They just don't make boats like this anymore, it's a shame.

I know Macojoe likes that Starboard - but I'm going for more of the Emmitt Fitz look. I'll be adding some nice teak to whatever I buy.

[reelapeelin]

Teakers or Starboarders...if you love a V20 you're at home here...look forward to hearin' how it goes w/ your sea-trial...pics if you can... 8)...

[macojoe]

Don't get me wrong!! Teak is great looking!! I love it!!

But I use my boat and use it HARD!! I commercial fish from it all summer, Bass, Fluke, Scup, Sea Bass, Blue fish, and Cod.

Teak has no place on my boat!! It goes days even weeks sometimes with out one drop of water to clean it (except rain) I have no time for detailing!!

This is why I am the King of Starboard!! ;D

Good luck!!

[buckleyjr]

I am now an owner of a v21! Purchased it yesterday, but can't bring it home for another two weeks. Previous owner was the origional buyer, took great care of her and was definitelly sad to let her go.

Here are some pictures:

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y146/buckleyjr/BoatPictures005.jpg

Here is the helm. The Loran, Fishfinder and compass are enclosed in a lockable cabinet (Starboard I think), so you don't have to lug them on and off the boat...

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y146/buckleyjr/PDR_0894.jpg

Love that Carolina flair!

http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y146/buckleyjr/BoatPictures006.jpg

[fillet1]

CONGRATS!!

That Boat Looks really clean!!!!!

You are going to love it. What kind of hours are on the motor?

[Pipe_Dream]

She looks great, Buckley! Welcome to the fold! :)

[chumbucket]

Very nice! Congrats on the purchase and best of luck with it. ;D

[macojoe]

Good luck!!!!!!!!!

[buckleyjr]

Thanks all. Hours weren't tracked, but engine has been very well maintained and is in good condition.

[labii]

You are going to love that boat ! Welcome and good luck with her .

[Crusher]

buckleyjr, congrats I looked at that boat two years ago,and posted for sale on this sight a couple times. I think cv checked it out also. As you said it looks to be in great condition and was well taken care of. Where do you live and boat? Crusher

[CT_V-20]

Congrats & welcome to the club

[shicks007]

Very clean boat, I'm sure you will love it!

[buckleyjr]

I actually found this boat from one of the threads from a posting on the site. Crusher, Reelapin and Lucky Strike had spoken well of the boat so I didn't mind driving 2 hours to see it. Thank you! Goes to show this site is such a great resource - and I definitelly owe you guys a few rounds!

I will be boating in central/northern NJ. Manasquan Inlet/Barnegat Bay area. Though I am considering bringing the boat up to Connecticut later thi ssummer on a lake since I don't have a slip yet. My in-laws live on the water. First thing I'll do when I get this home is go over every inch so I am familiar with everything. I also want to add so teak trip - I know, more work, but I enjoy working on my boat as much as using it. So probably won't see the water untill June/July.

[reelapeelin]

You sure gotta nice boat...hope we hear lots about it...and no, you can't post too many PICTURES... ;D...

Get W/ bigshrimpin and start a Gallery...